A client phoned me today and complained that she recently
spent over $2000 for removal of asbestos ceiling in the house she bought 10
months ago, which I inspected and produced with a report.
She claimed that I told her that asbestos ceiling was fine. She
listened to me and suffered loss. We did not counter argue but asked to go back
and review the report before having further discussion.
We then found clear wording in our report:
“Texture
coated ceiling may contain asbestos. Refer expert for further opinion. Do not
brake the texture ceiling coating without protection.”
I do not think she intentionally took the chance and blamed
me for misleading or negligent, but why she felt that she got misled when we
clearly mentioned asbestos ceiling in the report? The problem must be related
with our onsite verbal consultation.
Most client ordered inspections in a situation when they faced
critical lifetime decision making. Most client ordered inspections because they
loved a house. Like normal human being, they would selectively listen to our
inspection outcomes. Even though they tried to memorise our conversions as much
as they could, they would naturally remember the information which is pleased for
them, i.e. positive information and make their own summary. “You mean the house
is not leaking?” “So there are no major issues” such selective summaries out
from client’s selective listening are familiar to most inspectors.
I would clearly mention about cost involved with asbestos
removal, potential danger to contractors dealing with it and potential harm to
occupants exposed to unprotected asbestos. However, she only remembered
information such as “as long as protected and remaining undisturbed asbestos ceiling
will have no adverse effect to occupants health and safety”. She likely even
further selectively listened and summed as “asbestos ceiling will have no
adverse effect to occupants”.
There is no doubt that onsite verbal consultation is
extremely important for clients to efficiently and clearly understand our inspection
reports, verbal consultation must be accompanied by properly drafted written
report.
